ENZHMS
Link Copiedcheck_circle
Auto News

Are Toll Freezes Draining Taxpayers’ Money?

Kumeran Sagathevan

Share via

y-u-yiut-jw---r--e.jpg


Pressure is mounting on the government to declassify highway concession agreements and rethink toll policy, as critics warn that repeated toll freezes funded by public compensation are fiscally unsustainable and unfair to taxpayers.

Transport economist Dr Rosli Azad Khan said concession agreements remain hidden under the Official Secrets Act, denying the public visibility over how taxpayer money is committed. Speaking to the New Straits Times, he said declassification would improve transparency, strengthen accountability and allow for a fairer toll framework.

Rosli argued that freezing toll rates offers short-term relief to motorists but simply shifts the cost to taxpayers through compensation payments. He described the practice as “double taxation”, with the public paying tolls while also funding compensation via taxes, effectively protecting private operators with public funds.

Meanwhile, Universiti Teknologi Mara’s Dr Mohamad Idham Md Razak said toll compensation has become a quasi-subsidy that disproportionately benefits higher-income households reliant on private vehicles. Since 2016, RM7.7 billion has been spent on such payments, money he said could have delivered far greater returns if invested in public transport.


MRT-Corp-SSP-Line-May-PLUS-Highway-Sg-Buloh-Toll-1-scaled-full_normal.jpg


Although this year’s RM591.5 million allocation to freeze toll hikes on 10 highways signals some fiscal restraint, Idham said it fails to address the underlying problem. He called for renegotiated concession terms, including variable tolling, partial buybacks or revenue-sharing models, to reduce dependence on recurring compensation.

Transport think tank MY Mobility Vision echoed these concerns. Co-founder Rahman Hussin said toll compensation is effectively a broad-based subsidy for private car use, paid for by all Malaysians, including rural communities and households without vehicles.

Rahman noted that successive governments have relied on compensation to defer toll hikes, with RM7.7 billion spent over the past decade. While this year’s allocation is among the lowest in recent years, based on figures reported, he said the funds could instead support thousands of daily bus trips or expanded feeder services.


Mercedes-S-Class-Level-4-Self-Driving-Robotaxis-Debut-In-Abu-Dhabi-Mercedes-Benz-launches-Level-4-self-driving-S-Class-robotaxis-in-Abu-Dhabi-partnering-with-Chinese-software-firm-Momenta-(36).png


Instead, compensation has become a recurring expense that stabilises toll rates without expanding capacity or reducing car dependence. He added that payments often extend to mature, profitable highways as well as weaker concessions.

Rahman and former deputy transport minister Datuk Ab Aziz Kaprawi urged the government to redirect funds from toll compensation towards system-wide transport improvements, including better bus services and first- and last-mile connectivity.

With the National Transport Policy targeting lower private vehicle dependence and higher public transport use, critics say the continued reliance on toll compensation runs counter to national goals, raising questions over how long Malaysia can afford to keep freezing its transport choices.

Source: NST , NST


Share This Article

More then half his life spend being obsessed with all thing go-fast, performance and automotive only to find out he's actually Captain Slow behind the wheels...oh well!

Share via

JPJ Running Numbers

KUALA LUMPUR

VSA4819

SELANGOR

BSV2920

JOHOR

JH7613J

PULAU PINANG

PSH5424

PERAK

APN2134

PAHANG

CFJ4636

KEDAH

KGJ9130

NEGERI SEMBILAN

NEM6571

KOTA KINABALU

SJV2938

KUCHING

QAB704Q

Last updated 23 Nov, 2026

Fuel Price

Petrol

RON 95

RM 3.97

+1.38

RON 97

RM 4.90

+1.75

RON 100

RM 7.20

+2.20

VPR

RM 8.23

+2.00

Diesel

EURO 5 B10

RM 5.12

+2.08

EURO 5 B7

RM 5.32

+2.08

Last updated 30 Apr, 2026

Related News

Auto News
Toll Exemptions On Dec 23, 24 For Class 1 Vehicles

Toll Exemptions On Dec 23, 24 For Class 1 Vehicles

The government has announced free tolls on December 23 and 24 for the Christmas holiday.

21-12-2024
Auto News
Two Days Of Free Toll For Deepavali This Weekend

Two Days Of Free Toll For Deepavali This Weekend

The government has decided to exempt highway users from toll charges in conjunction with the Deepavali celebration.

10-11-2023
Auto News
Free Toll Ends Today

Free Toll Ends Today

The four-day free toll which began on April 19 until April 21 will end today on Monday (April 24).

24-04-2023
Auto News
Free 'Rahmah' Toll For Aidilfitri To Cost Government RM93m - Ahmad Maslan

Free 'Rahmah' Toll For Aidilfitri To Cost Government RM93m - Ahmad Maslan

Government will bear approximately RM93 million to implement the free Rahmah toll initiative.

21-04-2023
Auto News
2.3 Million Vehicles Expected Daily On Three Major Highways During Raya - PLUS, KL - Karak And East Coast Expressway 1

2.3 Million Vehicles Expected Daily On Three Major Highways During Raya - PLUS, KL - Karak And East Coast Expressway 1

LLM announces more than 2.3 million vehicles expected to flood daily on three major expressways.

19-04-2023
Auto News
Highway Maintenance Work Halted For Smooth Traffic Flow, Says Nanta

Highway Maintenance Work Halted For Smooth Traffic Flow, Says Nanta

The government confirms highway maintenance work will be halted to ensure smooth traffic flow.

19-04-2023
Auto News
4 Days Of Toll Exemptions For Eid Celebration

4 Days Of Toll Exemptions For Eid Celebration

The government announced free toll rates across 33 highway concessionaires on April 19 through April 21, as well as April 24.

18-04-2023
Auto News
Govt’s Initiative To Lessen Traffic Jams Through Barrier-Free System

Govt’s Initiative To Lessen Traffic Jams Through Barrier-Free System

The Malaysian government will implement a new toll system to prevent traffic congestion due to outdated toll technology currently in use in the nation.

21-03-2023

Latest News

Auto News
Women Want Female  E-Hailing Drivers. But Are There Enough Options In Malaysia?

Women Want Female E-Hailing Drivers. But Are There Enough Options In Malaysia?

Looking for female e-hailing drivers in Malaysia? Explore women-only rides, service availability, passenger safety and legal transport requirements.

18-11-2026
Auto News
Malaysia Toll Abolition Explained: RM400 Billion And Highway Concessions

Malaysia Toll Abolition Explained: RM400 Billion And Highway Concessions

Why could abolishing Malaysia's highway tolls cost RM400 billion? Explore highway concessions, toll payments and alternatives to nationwide toll abolition.

17-11-2026
Auto News
GWM Malaysia 2026 Year-End Deals: Prices, Warranties And Financing Offers

GWM Malaysia 2026 Year-End Deals: Prices, Warranties And Financing Offers

GWM Malaysia's 2026 year-end deals include the ORA Good Cat from RM94,000, Haval H6 HEV privileges, WEY G9 financing and Tank SUV warranties.

16-11-2026
Auto News
Honda Sumber Auto Edaran PJ Closes After 25 Years Of Operations

Honda Sumber Auto Edaran PJ Closes After 25 Years Of Operations

Honda Sumber Auto Edaran PJ has closed after 25 years, with over 27,000 cars sold. Here's what existing Honda customers should know.

16-11-2026
Auto News
All-New Nissan X-Trail e-POWER x e-4ORCE Makes First Public Appearance In Malaysia

All-New Nissan X-Trail e-POWER x e-4ORCE Makes First Public Appearance In Malaysia

The new Nissan X-Trail e-POWER x e-4ORCE makes its first public road appearance in KL ahead of its Q4 2026 Malaysia launch. Here's what we know.

16-11-2026
Auto News
Proton Sales 2026: Geely-Based Models Overtake Homegrown Cars

Proton Sales 2026: Geely-Based Models Overtake Homegrown Cars

Geely-based Protons lead homegrown models in 2026 registrations. But the e.MAS lineup and Saga sales reveal a more interesting story.

13-11-2026
Auto News
Johor Highway Upgrades: PLUS And Senai-Desaru May Open Early

Johor Highway Upgrades: PLUS And Senai-Desaru May Open Early

Two Johor highway stretches on PLUS and Senai-Desaru may open early in 2027. Here's where they are, proposed dates and what drivers should know.

13-11-2026
Auto News
Loke Says Some Welcomed His Resignation, Urges JPJ To Maintain Enforcement

Loke Says Some Welcomed His Resignation, Urges JPJ To Maintain Enforcement

Anthony Loke says some cheered his resignation, expecting JPJ's overloaded lorry crackdown to ease. Will enforcement continue without him?

12-11-2026

Show More

trending_flat

Malaysia First Used Car and EV Consignment Platform

This is the best place to sell your car at true market value. Instead of accepting low dealer trade-ins, we handle everything and connect your car directly to genuine buyers for the highest price.

I want to consign my car! Trade-in price too low.

CariCarz Automall

Understanding CariCarzAutomall Consignment Plan

Approved 200-Check Points Inspection

7 Day Money Back Guarantee

One Year Extended Warranty

No Hidden Charge

Carz Automedia Malaysia Logo
About Us

CarzAutoMedia: Stay connected to the latest car news! Get instant updates on new releases, industry trends, and automotive innovations. Your go-to source for 24/7 coverage of everything automotive.

© 2026 CariCarz.com. All Rights Reserved.