Dr Wins Landmark Clone Car Case, JPJ Ordered To Pay RM139,000 For Negligence!
-full_normal.jpg)
Pic Source: FMT
In a groundbreaking verdict today, the High Court issued a significant ruling, holding the Road Transport Department (JPJ) accountable for its failure to maintain accurate vehicle registration records. The case was initiated by a doctor who, unbeknownst to her, purchased a cloned 2013 Toyota Vellfire three years ago. In May of last year, she filed a lawsuit against the Penang JPJ director, the JPJ director-general, and the federal government, following the JPJ's seizure of her vehicle ten months after her purchase due to alleged tampering with the chassis and engine numbers.
The court has awarded Dr. Hema Thiyagu RM139,000 in damages, equivalent to the car's purchase price, after concluding that JPJ had violated its statutory obligations. Dr. Hema, aged 33, asserted in her lawsuit that JPJ had not provided a satisfactory explanation for failing to detect the tampering during the vehicle's registration process.
Her attorney, K. Simon Murali, argued that JPJ exhibited negligence in permitting the chassis and engine numbers of the car to be registered under a different vehicle. He contended that, according to JPJ's presented chronology in court, the stolen car was registered in Ipoh using the chassis and engine numbers from a previously registered vehicle in Johor.
Murali further contended that, based on testimonies from JPJ witnesses, there was no evidence that the original owner of the Vellfire had been present during the ownership transfer in Ipoh, despite legal requirements. Following that point, he asserted, the stolen car changed hands multiple times illegally before Dr. Hema unknowingly acquired it. In its defense, JPJ claimed that Dr. Hema's car was cloned and had been reported stolen in Labu, Negeri Sembilan, in 2019, while the chassis and engine numbers originated from the other vehicle in Johor.
-full_normal.jpg)
The Johor-registered vehicle had been in the possession of an insurer following an accident in 2018 and was auctioned off the following year. A subsequent buyer, during an attempt to change the ownership, discovered that the vehicle was "already registered," as stated in JPJ's defense statement. JPJ argued that it was not obligated to inspect vehicles before registering them, as such responsibilities fell under Puspakom. It asserted that its registration process relied solely on the required documents and, therefore, it had no legal obligation to explain to Dr. Hema why her car was seized.
In his verdict, Justice Anand Ponnudurai stated that the JPJ director-general bore the responsibility of maintaining an accurate vehicle register, particularly for vehicles flagged as cloned. He emphasized that JPJ should have promptly seized the cloned vehicle upon its discovery.
Justice Anand noted that in Dr. Hema's case, her lack of awareness regarding the cloned vehicle was understandable since there had been multiple previous owners, which did not raise any suspicion. He pointed out that JPJ had evidence as early as December 6, 2019, eight months before Dr. Hema's purchase, suggesting the possibility of the Vellfire being cloned, but no action was taken.
Consequently, Justice Anand concluded that both the Penang JPJ director and the JPJ director-general had violated their statutory duties. He awarded Dr. Hema RM139,000 in damages and RM10,000 in costs, to be paid by the federal government, which was named as the third defendant. Senior federal counsel Muhammad Sinti represented JPJ and the federal government.
Written By
Kumeran Sagathevan
More then half his life spend being obsessed with all thing go-fast, performance and automotive only to find out he's actually Captain Slow behind the wheels...oh well!
JPJ Running Numbers
KUALA LUMPUR
VSA4819
SELANGOR
BSV2920
JOHOR
JH7613J
PULAU PINANG
PSH5424
PERAK
APN2134
PAHANG
CFJ4636
KEDAH
KGJ9130
NEGERI SEMBILAN
NEM6571
KOTA KINABALU
SJV2938
KUCHING
QAB704Q
Last updated 23 Nov, 2026
Fuel Price
Petrol
RON 95
RM 3.97
+1.38
RON 97
RM 4.90
+1.75
RON 100
RM 7.20
+2.20
VPR
RM 8.23
+2.00
Diesel
EURO 5 B10
RM 5.12
+2.08
EURO 5 B7
RM 5.32
+2.08
Last updated 30 Apr, 2026
Related News
JPJ Removes Daily Limit Quota for Queue Numbers at All Offices
The Road Transport Department has announced the removal of the daily limit quota for queue numbers at all its offices.
19-02-2026
Summons Discounts for Foreign Vehicles Will Be Reviewed – MOT
The Transport Ministry will review traffic summons discounts offered to foreign vehicles, says minister Anthony Loke.
30-01-2026
Pos Malaysia Will Stop Issuing Physical Road Tax From Feb 2026 Onwards
Pos Malaysia has announced that JPJ will stop issuing physical road tax for private vehicles beginning Feb 1, 2026.
27-01-2026
Luxury Cars, Fake Plates: JPJ LPT1 Cracks Down
Luxury cars with fake plates were among several vehicles seized as JPJ cracks down on LPT1 offenders.
27-01-2026
JPJ Lifts Travel Proof Rule for Physical Driving Licence
JPJ lifts the travel proof rule, allowing motorists to apply for a physical licence without overseas travel justification.
23-01-2026
Puspakom - New Brake Inspection Rules for Heavy Vehicles
Puspakom’s new brake inspection rules for heavy vehicles target unsafe brake settings that increase accident risks.
22-01-2026
JPJ Cracks Down on Illegal Vehicle Use by Foreign Drivers
JPJ - enforcement against illegal vehicle use by foreign drivers, warning that Malaysian owners remain legally responsible.
21-01-2026
Dec 2025 Vehicle Sales: Petrol Up 24.5%, xEV Hits Record 12.4%
Dec 2025 registrations rose 24.5%, lifting Malaysia’s auto market past 800,000 units as xEV share hit 12.4%.
11-01-2026
Latest News
Women Want Female E-Hailing Drivers. But Are There Enough Options In Malaysia?
Looking for female e-hailing drivers in Malaysia? Explore women-only rides, service availability, passenger safety and legal transport requirements.
18-11-2026
Malaysia Toll Abolition Explained: RM400 Billion And Highway Concessions
Why could abolishing Malaysia's highway tolls cost RM400 billion? Explore highway concessions, toll payments and alternatives to nationwide toll abolition.
17-11-2026
GWM Malaysia 2026 Year-End Deals: Prices, Warranties And Financing Offers
GWM Malaysia's 2026 year-end deals include the ORA Good Cat from RM94,000, Haval H6 HEV privileges, WEY G9 financing and Tank SUV warranties.
16-11-2026
Honda Sumber Auto Edaran PJ Closes After 25 Years Of Operations
Honda Sumber Auto Edaran PJ has closed after 25 years, with over 27,000 cars sold. Here's what existing Honda customers should know.
16-11-2026
All-New Nissan X-Trail e-POWER x e-4ORCE Makes First Public Appearance In Malaysia
The new Nissan X-Trail e-POWER x e-4ORCE makes its first public road appearance in KL ahead of its Q4 2026 Malaysia launch. Here's what we know.
16-11-2026
Proton Sales 2026: Geely-Based Models Overtake Homegrown Cars
Geely-based Protons lead homegrown models in 2026 registrations. But the e.MAS lineup and Saga sales reveal a more interesting story.
13-11-2026
Johor Highway Upgrades: PLUS And Senai-Desaru May Open Early
Two Johor highway stretches on PLUS and Senai-Desaru may open early in 2027. Here's where they are, proposed dates and what drivers should know.
13-11-2026
Loke Says Some Welcomed His Resignation, Urges JPJ To Maintain Enforcement
Anthony Loke says some cheered his resignation, expecting JPJ's overloaded lorry crackdown to ease. Will enforcement continue without him?
12-11-2026
Show More
trending_flat
Malaysia First Used Car and EV Consignment Platform
This is the best place to sell your car at true market value. Instead of accepting low dealer trade-ins, we handle everything and connect your car directly to genuine buyers for the highest price.

Understanding CariCarzAutomall Consignment Plan


Approved 200-Check Points Inspection

7 Day Money Back Guarantee

One Year Extended Warranty

No Hidden Charge